Geo-testing has emerged as a powerful methodology for marketers seeking to gain causal insights into the effectiveness of their media spend. In an age where every marketing dollar matters, geo-testing provides the clarity needed to refine strategies and optimize budgets. Here’s a comprehensive step-by-step guide to integrating geo-testing into your marketing strategy, ensuring you maximize its potential.

Step 1: Understand the Types of Geo Tests

Before integrating geo-testing into your strategy, it's important to grasp the two main types of geo tests:

‍

1. Holdout Tests:

• Purpose: Determine the incremental lift of current media spending.
• How It Works: Media is turned off in selected geographic regions (holdout regions), while other regions continue with business-as-usual spending.
• Use Case: Measure the incremental impact of your current marketing tactics.

2. Scale Tests:

• Purpose: Measure the potential return of increasing media spend.
• How It Works: Increase spend in specific geographic regions (test regions) while maintaining the standard spending level in other regions (control regions).
• Use Case: Determine if additional investment in a particular marketing channel yields a positive ROI.

Step 2: Define Your Test Objectives and Hypotheses

Clearly outline your goals and hypotheses to determine what you want to learn from the test.

Example Objectives:

• Measure the incremental impact of social media ads on overall sales.
• Determine the optimal level of investment in non-brand search.
• Evaluate whether increasing email marketing spend leads to higher revenue.
  
  

Formulate Hypotheses:

• "Increasing Facebook ad spend by 50% will increase conversions by 20%."
• "Scaling Google search ads in non-brand keywords will double the ROI."

Step 3: Select Test and Control Locations

Choosing the right geographic regions is critical for accurate testing.

Key Criteria for Selection:

• Similarity: Ensure regions are similar in demographics, economic conditions, and historical performance.
• Market Size: Select regions with enough volume to generate statistically significant results.
• Isolation: Minimize cross-regional media exposure to maintain data purity.
  
  

Finding Comparison Cities:

• Use demographic, behavioral, and economic data to identify regions similar to your test region.
• Leverage tools like Stella, which can automatically analyze and suggest comparable regions.

Step 4: Design Your Test Framework

1. Duration:

• Holdout Tests: Run for a minimum of two to four weeks to observe meaningful trends.
• Scale Tests: Allow a longer timeframe (4-8 weeks) to capture the full impact of increased spending.
  
  

2. Group Assignment:

• Assign regions randomly to test and control groups to avoid selection bias.
• Ensure the control group remains isolated from the marketing activity.

Step 5: Launch the Test

Execute your geo-testing plan:

• Holdout Tests: Turn off media spending in holdout regions.
• Scale Tests: Increase media spend in test regions while maintaining standard levels in control regions.

Step 6: Monitor and Adjust in Real-Time

• Track the performance of both test and control regions throughout the test period.
• Adjust spending as necessary to ensure statistical significance.

Step 7: Analyze the Results

After completing the test period, compare the results of the test and control groups.

Key Metrics to Analyze:

• Incremental Lift: (Test Group Conversions - Control Group Conversions) / Control Group Conversions
• Incremental ROI (iROI): Incremental Revenue / Incremental Ad Spend

Step 8: Apply Insights and Optimize Strategies

Translate your findings into actionable strategies:

For Positive Results:

• Scale Up: Increase spend in regions/channels where the test showed positive ROI.
• Replicate: Apply the same strategy to other regions with similar demographics and behaviors.
  
  

For Negative Results:

• Reallocate: Shift budget to more effective channels or regions.
• Refine Strategy: Adjust messaging, targeting, or frequency based on insights.

Step 9: Test Frequently and Continuously Improve

Testing is not a one-time activity. Regularly conduct geo tests to account for dynamic market conditions such as:

• Seasonal fluctuations.
• Competitor activities.
• Changes in portfolio mix.
  
  

By testing frequently, you can stay ahead of market trends and refine your marketing strategy for optimal impact.

Conclusion

Geo-testing is a valuable investment in your marketing strategy, offering deep insights into the causal impact of media spend. By following this step-by-step guide, marketers can confidently integrate geo-testing into their strategy and optimize their media budget for maximum ROAS. Tools like Stella can further streamline the process, ensuring that your geo-testing efforts are efficient and data-driven.

‍

Ready to take that next step with your paid media program? Schedule a demo with Stella today and discover how you can make smarter media investments.

‍